FitMitTuro Fitness Podcast
Struggling to stay consistent with your fitness and nutrition while juggling work, family, or a busy schedule? You’re not alone—and you’re in the right place.
Hosted by strength coach and educator Turo Virta, this podcast delivers no-BS advice for women 40 and older, busy professionals, and anyone tired of quick fixes and yo-yo dieting.
Tune in each week for powerful solo episodes and expert interviews on topics like:
- Fat loss without tracking every calorie
- Emotional eating and mindset
- Reverse dieting and metabolism
- Hormonal changes, menopause, and belly fat
- Sustainable workouts for busy lifestyles
- Fitness motivation when you feel stuck
Whether you're restarting your journey, feeling frustrated with plateaus, or looking for training solutions that actually fit your life—this show is for you.
🎧 New episodes every week. Subscribe and take back control of your health—without the obsession.
FitMitTuro Fitness Podcast
Supplements After 40: What’s Worth Your Money and What Isn’t? with Dr. Joshua Plant
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Walk into a health store or spend five minutes on social media and you’ll find supplements promising better sleep, more energy, faster fat loss, stronger muscles, better hormones, improved brain health and even longer life.
But which supplements are actually worth taking?
And which ones are mostly expensive marketing?
In this episode, I sit down with Dr. Joshua Plant, who holds a PhD in Biomedical Sciences from Harvard University, has worked in cancer research and spent around two decades in the supplement industry.
Josh is also the founder of The Science Standard and host of The Dr. Plant Podcast, where he focuses on what the evidence actually says about supplements, quality and health claims.
One of the biggest ideas from our conversation is simple:
Supplements should supplement something. They shouldn’t replace the fundamentals.
Josh compares supplements to clothing. You don’t wear the same clothes in every season. In the same way, what you might benefit from can depend on your diet, age, lifestyle, sleep, stress and activity level.
We talk about creatine, protein powder, collagen, vitamin D, magnesium, omega-3s, multivitamins, greens powders, fat burners and more.
Josh explains why he considers creatine one of the strongest options for adults over 40, particularly because of its role in training performance and growing interest around cognitive health.
We also discuss why protein powder can be useful mainly because it makes it easier to increase protein without adding a huge amount of calories, but why whole-food protein should still make up most of the diet.
And we go deep on collagen.
Josh explains why collagen is not a complete protein, why it shouldn’t replace whey or another complete protein source, and why its potential benefits for skin and joint comfort are much more modest than many marketing claims suggest.
We also talk about:
- why most people may be taking too many supplements
- why multivitamins are often unnecessary
- the risk of getting too much of certain nutrients
- why supplements are so easy to over-market
- how to decide whether you actually need a supplement
- creatine after 40
- creatine and cognitive health
- protein powder versus whole foods
- whey versus plant-based protein
- whether expensive protein powder is actually better
- collagen for skin and joints
- why collagen should not replace regular protein
- vitamin D
- magnesium and sleep
- omega-3s
- greens powders
- detox products
- fat burners
- third-party testing
- why expensive supplements are not automatically better
- what a healthy 48-year-old woman should actually prioritize
- what Josh would buy if he only had €50 per month to improve his health
One of my favorite moments comes right at the end.
When I ask Josh whether someone with only €50 per month should spend it on supplements, his answer is basically:
No. Save your money first.
And if there were one supplement he’d prioritize because it is difficult to get meaningful amounts through food, he would lean toward creatine.
Connect with Dr. Joshua Plant:
The Science Standard:
https://www.thesciencestandard.com/
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/drjoshplant/
LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/joshua-plant-phd-980552337/
The Dr. Plant Podcast on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/@DrPlantPodcast
Learn more about Turo and FitMitTuro:
Website & Coaching:
https://personaltrainerturo.it
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/personaltrainer_turo
TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@personaltrainer_turo
FitMitTuro Fitness Podcast:
https://www.fitmitturo.com/
Apple Podcasts:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/fitmitturo-fitness-podcast/id1512446261
Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/1VLf4hjt7M3tho6AURKJqa
Try The Consistency Reset
My new personalized coaching app for women 35–55 who are tired of starting over with diets, workouts, and healthy habits.
Get simple daily actions, realistic workouts, practical nutrition habits, and Reset Mode to help you keep going when life gets busy.
Take the quiz and build your personalized plan here: studio.com/turo/consistency-reset
Welcome back to the Fit Mi Turo Fitness podcast. Walk into almost any health store and spend five minutes on social media, and you will find supplements promising better sleep, more energy, faster fat loss, stronger muscles, better hormones, improved brain health, and maybe even longer life. And especially after 40, it can start to feel like you need an entire cabinet of pills and powders just to stay healthy. But which supplements actually have a good evidence behind them? Which ones might be useful only in specific situations, and which ones are mostly expensive marketing? My guest today is Dr. Joshua Plant. Joshua has a PhD in biomedical sciences from Harvard University and extensive experience in the supplement industry. He's also the founder of the Science Standard and host of the Dr. Plant podcast, where he focuses on what the evidence actually says about supplements, quality, and better health decisions. Today, I want to make supplements simple. We are going to talk about creatine, protein, magnesium, vitamin D, omega threes, collagen, multivitamins, and some other supplements. People over 40 are constantly being told they need. But more importantly, I want to understand how we can tell whether supplement is actually worth taking in the first place. Josh, welcome to the podcast.
Unknown:Well, thanks for having me. I appreciate the opportunity.
Turo Virta:Awesome. First, before we get into topics, please tell a little bit who you are, what you are, where you are living. You have a family, just the normal things before anything about your studies and what do you do, like who you are. Yeah,
Unknown:I've got. I have to be careful. My it's 7am. right now here in Fairnix, Arizona, and my 13-year-old's getting ready for school, so I have four children. Wife married for 2425 years, and three of my children are studying at the university right now. And then I've got my 13 year old still at home. And yeah, we've lived all over. We lived in Boston, Washington D.C. We lived in Utah, and now we're kind of making Arizona our home. So
Turo Virta:nice,
Unknown:a fairly simple life.
Turo Virta:Yeah, yeah, no, but that's it. Sounds very busy life. Yeah, or now maybe four
Unknown:children. There's no way to not be busy.
Turo Virta:Yeah, yeah. Then what about your your what is what you are doing like obviously a doctor. What is your day-to-day life looking? What what is what you are doing? Yeah,
Unknown:so I am a I teach at a university. I got my doctorate in biomedical sciences. So I work for both the National Institutes of Health, which is the United States lab in Washington D.C. studying breast cancer, I continued my work in my graduate work at Harvard, where I was studying how cells kind of lose their up from their down. They become disoriented, which is kind of the precursor to cancer. Cellular asymmetry is the fancy way of saying that, and then I, after that, I kind of went into the private industry, helping companies kind of develop products. Spent about 20 years in the supplement space, and I stepped back from that largely due to, I would say, kind of moral reasons. And now I kind of teach at the university genetics and microbiology. So my day to day is going in, inspiring kids to learn more about genetics and microbiology and human health, teaching future doctors and nurses.
Turo Virta:Nice. That sounds interesting. I'm curious to learn from you. So after you have you have spending so many years inside the supplement in industry, do you think, first of all, if most people are taking too many supplements,
Unknown:are people taking too many supplements? Yes, I feel very confident in saying yes to that. And you know, if we stepped back 100 years ago, then the answer may not be yes. But the the way in which our food is fortified with a lot of vitamins, we have access to more food today. We're aware of where different vitamins are found. If people eat a well balanced diet, there are very few, if any, supplements that they need to be taking. And with that, I'm going to always give a little bit of an asterisk. I look at supplements as things that are supplemental. They're supposed to be in addition to. They're not a replacement of. And I think a lot of people look at things as a replacement of. And so the way I always interpret supplements is, if it's cold outside, I supplement. My body with a jacket. If it's sunny outside, I supplement my body with a hat. There's not going to be one supplement clothes that I wear because my environment changes fast. And so I look at supplements as a way of looking at the season that you are in. If you're under a lot of stress, you know maybe some ashwagandha can help, but it's not something you're taking every day, so to speak. Or hey, I'm getting older and I'm worrying about muscle loss. Okay, well maybe you can supplement with creatine to help prevent that muscle loss, but it's not something that you need to be taking your whole life. And so in that thing, it's a little bit of kind of understanding the season you're in, and then putting on the proper supplemental clothes to help that season.
Turo Virta:Ah, that's very, very well said. Thank you. What about then? If you opened opened the supplement cabinet of the average health conscious, let's say 45 year old, what would you expect to find that probably isn't doing very much.
Unknown:Yeah, so a lot of the stuff out there that I think is kind of overhyped. I'm going to kind of say anything that requires a blend, multiple ingredients in there, because usually what is behind those products is just a lot of marketing, right? We've heard of these like you know the athletic greens and those types of products where they're like $80 and it's got 80 different ingredients in it. And so if you look on the back of your supplement fact panel and you're seeing numerous ingredients, I guarantee you that that supplement is not really providing specific value. It is taking maybe one of those ingredients and it's using that to kind of drive a claim, but you don't even know how much of that ingredient is in it. So I am a big fan of taking very simple, basic supplements, right? Kind of the generic ones. So I would say stuff that has a lot of different ingredients in it, you're likely not needing. I'm not a big fan of a multivitamin. I don't think multivitamins are needed, and they probably can do more harm than good. So I would probably stop taking a multivitamin. You're getting enough of your B vitamins through the everyday diet. Much rather tell people to eat an orange than take a vitamin C. All right, and so I think a multivitamin is overrated, and I think depending on the diet in America we don't eat a lot of fish, so I do think you do need an omega in America. But in Japan, you probably don't. You eat enough fish in Japan, so you're probably fine. So those are my big things. I'm a big believer that multivitamins are not needed.
Turo Virta:Yeah, no, I. It's it's funny. I I I feel exactly the same. I'm obviously I'm not in any expert. Like I, I have done my my research and everything, but this is like I have the feeling too that when people are telling like that multivitamins, that you know it's as to you take it kind of as insurance, but it's actually it's it's like you said what kind of harm or potential harm there is in multivitamins, for example. Yeah,
Unknown:so you run the risk of what's called overfortification or taking too many of vitamin, and so we get a lot of vitamins in our daily lives, and so there's actually what's considered to be the TUDL, the tolerable upper daily limit, and these are established. So if we go above those limits for extended periods of time, we're actually doing more harm than good to our body. Everything from taking some, for example, too much vitamin B6 can lead to neuropathy, right? Tingling of the fingers. Too much vitamin B 12 can actually inhibit your ability to absorb folate and to process folate. And so we have all of these different things. And when we're taking too much of a particular vitamin, it can really expose us to certain risks. And so this is why I always call it like this arms race. Is you'd have a multivitamin, and it used to give you like 100% of your daily allowance of something, and then somebody's like, "Oh, we need to make a better vitamin," and so they give you 200% of your daily allowance. And now you're looking, and you see on a drink to where there's, you know, 50,000% of your daily allowance of vitamin B 12, which is completely unnecessary and potentially harmful.
Turo Virta:Yeah. Oh, makes makes sense. What about then? What is what makes supplement such an easy category for marketing hype?
Unknown:I think supplements provide. Sorry, I'm dropping my blinds right here. This one's poking up. I think supplements provide a background for easy hype because health is something we all care about. We're all very passionate. Wanting to be healthy, we want to feel better. We want to look better, and and so because we have such a desire to look and feel better, we're very open to believing things that are overhyped. And this is a common play. It's it's I believe it's very unethical, right? To where you're playing on people's low points or fears, and you're then providing a huge promise to individuals where it's not necessarily delivering what it is, but because their belief or their hope to get to look better or to feel better is so powerful, they will ignore any critical thinking skills and they will believe that testimony that you have, and so I think in that scenario, that is why the supplement space is so ripe and overhyped. Now, even in that situation, I own a supplement company, but I am a big believer in that situation. Like, a the evidence on this is a four out of 10, right? And being honest in that, so that people, individuals, I do believe there's greater power in that honesty. But it's that area of where I think so many people are susceptible because they just have that desire to look and feel better.
Turo Virta:Yeah, absolutely. I I can totally agree. It's it's it's like, but it's it's nowadays it's it's kind of everything. It's it's with the food industry, with everything, and it's it's it's that marketing. What makes it so hard to actually say that what makes actually sense? Because obviously, all people like you don't have you don't need to have a PhD from from from university to understand it, and it's it's hard to understand like what you actually need, what would make sense. But what I what what I'm curious to know what about when when someone asks you, and I'm I'm sure you get this question a lot. So question they ask that what supplements should I then take, and what information do you need from the people who is asking before you can answer that responsibly?
Unknown:Yeah, well, I think it's important to understand what is their diet, right? What are they lacking in their diet, and what activities are they doing that may put their body into a different environment, and so in that situation, if a person let's say has a tough manual labor job, and it's kind of exhausting every day, you could look at kind of saying, okay, well, there is some evidence to kind of suggest curcumin, which is the kind of the active ingredient in turmeric, can help kind of decrease joint inflammation and joint stress. And so, in that scenario, if the person is out digging wells all day or moving around and their joints are stiff, supplementing with curcumin might be appropriate for the season of the life that they're in. Additionally, for individuals, I'm a big believer in creatine on the mental aspect, right? And so, individuals who are sleep deprived when they take creatine perform better. It has a neuroprotective type of properties in people that are sleep deprived, and so taking kind of creatine if you've had a bad night's sleep might be very beneficial to help you execute a little bit better throughout the day. You know there is a little bit of evidence with respect to individuals who are taking magnesium that they can sleep better, but if you're getting good enough sleep, you don't need the magnesium, right? And so, if you're doing what I always consider the behaviors first, you're making your room dark, you're making your room cold, you're turning off the screens an hour before you go to bed. If you're doing all of those things and you're getting a good night's sleep. You don't need to supplement with the magnesium, right? But for individuals who might their lifestyle requires them to have a screen on up until the time they go to bed, and a variety of other factors, that is where I would say, okay, it's time to put on the sweater. It's a cold environment. Supplement to help you sleep a little better. And so it's hard to say things that are useless to everybody because everybody has a different environment, a different lifestyle, and really kind of assessing: okay, where am I in my life, and what do I need? What clothes? What nutritional supplements do I need to put on for this season in my life?
Turo Virta:No, makes sense. Makes sense. What about then? Is there such a thing as a supplement everybody over 40 should take.
Unknown:No, in the short term, but the one that I would say is probably the best to take would be creatine. Evidence really strong evidence. Dr. Rick Kreider at Texas A&M did a lot of work on this, looking at individuals who supplement with creatine. They're able to retain their muscle mass longer. So right at once you're at at 40, you begin to kind of lose muscle mass every year. And what creatine is it creatine is in our cells, and what it is is it stores energy. Our cells can only really use what's called adenosine triphosphate (ATP) as its source of energy, and it gets that energy from glucose, our blood sugar levels, and it converts it to ATP, which our cells can use. But it burns through that ATP very quickly in just a few seconds. And so what it does is creatine is also in our cells, and what creatine does is it stores energy for it becomes what's called phosphocreatine, which then stores that energy. So as we burn through our ATP very quickly, The creatine donates its phosphates to the ATP and replenishes it, so it's like your battery backup for your phone. And so, this is very good for muscles, right? So if I'm going and I'm exercising, and let's say I usually would do 10 reps, all of a sudden, because my muscles would become exhausted, now I have phosphocreatine built up in my muscles. I can get another two reps out, and in turn, that can allow me to build more muscle. Now, creatine itself necessarily isn't going to build the muscle for you, but it gives you the energy to then build the more muscle. Where I'm really intrigued with creatine is the most energy-intensive cells in our body are our neurons, right? This brain, which is only a couple of pounds, consumes about 20% of our daily energy. It is just an energy-consuming machine, and so that phosphocreatine is very important to help make sure those neurons do not become exhausted of energy, And so, the there's growing evidence to suggest, especially among the elderly individuals, by taking that creatine, it may help. You're you're better at executing daily functions, cognitive reasoning, memory, focus, and so forth can help, and so I believe at 40 and plus, creatine is one of the better supplements that people could benefit from. And you're wanting to take five to 10 grams a day.
Turo Virta:Was there like talking with the creatine? I was reading something. There is some studies showing about preventing possibly about against Alzheimer. Is there what is the situation for other like health benefits? Not only building muscle. If somebody is not interested to build muscle, is there some like I know it's it's probably not, but it's well studied supplement, so it's totally safe.
Unknown:Yeah, it's very very safe. It's found in food, for example. You just have to eat a lot of steak to get the amount of creatine. But the the Alzheimer's, it doesn't necessarily help prevent it. People with Alzheimer's appear to help have better functioning. Now they haven't done a study because those studies are very difficult to do. You're needing to give people creatine for 40 years and then measure the rate of Alzheimer's between them. But because people seem to respond better with Alzheimer's on it, there is suggestion to believe in when we know the mechanism of how creatine works, that it can help delay the onset of Alzheimer's or dementia type stuff as well, but I don't. I think prevent is a strong word, but I would probably say kind of help limit the potential impact of Alzheimer's and dementias on the body.
Turo Virta:No, thank you. Yeah, makes makes totally sense. And then what is like you mentioned? You if you get it naturally from meat. What kind of meat, and what you? If you said that we would need like five to 10 grams per day, what it is? How you count? Is it going to be then five, or is it going to be 10? And if you are like how much meat you need to eat to get more or less, that would your body wish most ideal intake.
Unknown:Yeah. So this is it's hard to say because there's different ways in which you could prep the stuff, but typically you're going to have to look at about one kilo of beef a day to get the five to 10 grams of creatine. Wow. Yeah. So it's it's just something that is just very impractical, and this is why I do believe in the situation. Creatine is one of the supplements that is just impractical to get from your diet, but we do see the cognitive benefits from it. I'm also a big proponent of omega three taking it. People in Japan eat enough fish in the U.S. We don't eat a lot of fish. Right, so we need to supplement with it for the cognitive benefits and the cardiovascular benefits. So that's kind of, I think, the two that I would recommend for everyday individuals, at least in the Western Hemisphere, an omega and creatine.
Turo Virta:What about then protein? That is probably another another huge huge topic. So, does the average person need protein powder or some other protein supplement?
Unknown:Yeah, that is also. I I like to drink like a protein shake in the morning. It's an easy way for me to get protein, but in that scenario, you're wanting roughly about 100 grams of protein a day, and depending on your size and your activity level. But the challenge with a lot of people, especially in today's world, is getting those 100 grams of protein may be accompanied with quite a bit of other calories, right? So if I'm wanting 100 grams of protein, I'm getting a lot of different fats, different calories, you know, cholesterols, a variety of other things. And so the reason that I supplement with the protein is it allows me to get roughly 30 or 40 grams of protein for about 200 calories, and so I've got my good protein and I got it with very few calories, which then kind of helps me be a little bit better throughout the rest of the day. Because if I'm trying to get my 100 grams of protein, it could be easy to be like, oh well, look at I can, I'll have a a chicken sandwich. There's some chicken in it, but the chicken was deep fried. You know, the chicken is now submodern in a whole bunch of bread with mayonnaise. You name it, and then all of a sudden it's 1,600 calories to get the 40 grams of protein. Now there's individuals who are much more disciplined, who maybe cook the chicken breast very lean, very good protein, or who get their protein through plant sources and are able to associate those proteins together to make a complete protein. But with that being said, one of the better articles that came out it came out in Cell about two years ago, and this is a one of the top scientific journals in the world, and they show that the body is actually very, very good at responding to high amounts of protein. That we haven't really figured out what that upper limit of protein is, and so in this paper they looked at muscle synthesis, and we know that we can initiate muscle synthesis through the essential amino acid lysine. It's lysine that kind of will start that mTOR pathway, which causes muscle synthesis. And so they gave people increasing amounts of protein, and they found that that muscle synthesis continued to go up, and that they still haven't found that upper limit. And so, I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing to take too much protein, especially as you're older. You're needing more protein as you get older. Kind of counterintuitive. So supplementing with protein as you get older, I think is a good thing. But try to get it from your diet. I think is the best way to do it. Lean chicken breast, you know, soy, all great sources. I'm a big fan of whey protein, of getting the protein into your body.
Turo Virta:Yeah. What about? Is there difference? Like, of course, there are so many different protein powders. Are those what are most expensive usually generally better, or what is what is you mentioned whey protein? What is your recommendation with protein powder, or what when it matters which protein? Yeah. So
Unknown:the key with a protein powder is what's called the amino acids. You're wanting your a complete protein, which means you're wanting your essential amino acids to be as high concentration as possible. And whey protein, milk protein, is kind of the best one that's out there in the amount of those essential amino acids. But that doesn't mean you can't get it from plants. It's just a matter of combining the different plants together to make the complete protein, right? So beans by itself, no. Rice by itself, no. You combine the two, yes. And so you can still get it from a variety. I don't believe the expensive protein is really any different. There's like three or four different suppliers of all the whey protein in the world, right? And they supply it to all of the different protein people. Some people charge a lot, some people charge a little, but it came from the same source. So I am a big believer that the look for kind of your economical, your lower cost supplements are likely pretty much the same. In fact, there's a group. Out there called Consumer Lab, Consumer Labs, and they just buy supplements off the shelf and test them, and they have found no correlation based upon price and quality.
Turo Virta:What about when there is like different? You mentioned vegan proteins, then there is casein, egg protein, protein. What is when it makes sense to take, or is it whey always the best, or or is it is it combination, or for which individual you would recommend something else than whey?
Unknown:Yeah. So your body, the protein, we we kind of overcomplicate this a little bit. Protein is a word to encompasses all amino acids. There's 20 amino acids that our body uses to make our own body, right? All life on Earth, from humans to bacteria, use 20 amino acids, and so they it's just the combination of those amino acids put together and the different lengths of those amino acids put together that make the diversity of life. So it's like there's 26 letters in the alphabet, and with just those 26 letters, I can put those letters in different combinations in different order, and I can make every word imaginable, right? And it's those same 26 letters that make the Italian language, and it's those same 26 letters that make the English language. And I can create new words, you name it. And so, just 26 word letters can create infinite amount of words and languages, and just 20 amino acids can create infinite amount of proteins and species, and so when we talk about protein, what you're doing is you're eating the word, boom, the whole word. But I don't absorb the word. I break it down into the individual letters. My digestive system does, and then I reassemble it into my language, into my words. And so this is why the source of the protein isn't overly important. It's just a matter that you get all 20 of those letters. Specifically, there's nine that are called essential because my body can't make. I can make 11 of those letters myself, and there's nine I need to get from my diet. And so you really, when we talk about the quality of protein, it's just the amount per gram of protein. How much is of those nine amino acids? And if I'm eating a gram of protein, and 30% of that protein is from those nine essential amino acids, that's a pretty good protein, right? And so that's the key. That's what we mean about quality of protein: is how much of those essential amino acids is found in
Turo Virta:it, and what would be then those quality foods or proteins what we need.
Unknown:Yeah. So the best one out there, the one that has the highest of food that is out there, is whey. And then casing is, I think, right below it. You're going to see egg albumin is also pretty high on there. Soy is pretty high on it as a plant-based source. And then you have ones, as I said before, like rice, which maybe enriched in maybe five of the nine, and then pea protein is enriched in the other five, but you put them together, you're good. And so that's where I think in the scenario, whey, casein, soy, albumin, those are all what are called complete high quality proteins. And so I think in those areas that you just kind of base it off of your personal preference, taste. If I'm vegetarian, if I'm not, but there really is very minimal, if any, difference between a soy and a whey, for example.
Turo Virta:Yeah, no, it makes sense, and it's how I understand that, and what I heard, like, or also from my own experience, like, there is such a big difference how we are digesting. It could be a huge difference, like between at least for me, depending on brand, like and of course it's it's probably not about protein itself, but what is like what kind of other things are there in how well I'm digesting. So for me was when I found protein powder, what I digest exactly the same than let's say I would eat chicken breast. It feels same. Then I know probably that I I found the right protein or right supplement.
Unknown:Yeah, and there is that personal preference, right? Because breaking the word, right? When we can eat protein, we're eating the whole word, and some proteins are harder for other people to digest, right? And so there's a little bit of personal preference in there. Though I would be, I'm at fault for this, right? As I said before, I drink a protein shake in the morning, but it's better to get it from food and the. Reason is is you have what's called this metabolic effect from eating. So if I eat 100 grams of chicken breast, let's say, and I eat 100 gram or 100 calories of a protein shake, and they both have the same amount of protein, for me to get the protein out of the chicken breast, I actually will burn about 20 calories, and so I, in essence, it's this. It's called the thermogenic effect of food, and so I actually it's like exercising a little bit, right? There's 20 calories that I burn to get it out of like a processed food. It's like three to five calories, and so this is why individuals who have a whole food diet tend to be skinnier, even if they're eating the same amount of calories, is because they're spending up to 20% of their calories just to digest the food. But highly processed foods, they're pretty much already kind of digested for us, and so we're doing that. And that may not sound like a lot, but that's like 400 calories a day.
Turo Virta:Oh yeah, that's that's a lot.
Unknown:That's a McDonald's hamburger extra a day.
Turo Virta:Extra day, yeah. It may. I know. It's it sounds very very or almost too good to be true or hard to believe because it's it's it makes such a big difference. What about what about then collagen? It is it a replacement for normal protein powder?
Unknown:No, no. Collagen is not a complete protein, and so you're really kind of people who take collagen. You're not getting that those essential amino acids that can stimulate muscle growth. Now, there is some benefit to collagen. Collagen is unique because as you break down collagen protein, it doesn't have those essential amino acids in it. You'll break it down into these small little three amino acid groups, and it's. I don't want to get too technical, but though that amino acid group we absorb in those three little amino acids, and what that does is that can actually stimulate some of your own collagen production. So this is why some people supplement with collagen to kind of help with joints or help with wrinkles, and you can see a modest improvement in that. You know, you're ranging like, oh, my wrinkles got three to 10% better, or less, worse, I guess, where you could do that, and so it might stimulate some of your own collagen production, but it is not a way in which you should be supplementing for protein.
Turo Virta:Because I think that is where many people, especially women, it's because of it's because it says it's protein, and you know everybody hears that you you need a protein. Then it has that claims or or about better skin or or less wrinkles and all kind of thing again going deep to our emotions, what we really want, but and it's it's very popular nowadays. But yeah, it is
Unknown:very popular because then it's appealing to this. Where it's like, hey, I can look younger by just drinking this. And if you notice, I don't know, at least in U.S. labeling law, if you look on the back and it says protein and it has like 10 grams of collagen, if you go to the side and it says percent daily value, you notice that they have a number there that's less than what it should be. It's usually like a 0%, and the reason is is because it's not a complete protein. So you shouldn't be counting that protein towards your daily limit or towards
Turo Virta:your daily goal. What about then? What benefits actually have a decent evidence? What is there about collagen?
Unknown:Yeah, so collagen. There's some evidence that suggests that it can help with wrinkles, but like moderate, you know, like three to 5% improvement in the wrinkles. There's some evidence to suggest that it could help a little bit with joint discomfort, kind of moderate impact. But I would say that the collagen itself has probably been overused, overpromoted, kind of as this catch-all. And I think it's because people understand collagen is the most abundant protein in our body, right? It's it's if I have two cells in all animals, right? Here's two cells. A lot of times we imagine the cells next to each other, like we're like a building of bricks, all stacked. But there's actually a lot of space between our cells, and we call that space the extracellular matrix, and that's where collagen lives. It's a big protein, and it it allows our cells to move, right? It's like this rubber spot between our cells, so we can move. Plants don't have collagen, for example. That's why they don't they don't move, so they don't have collagen. Their cells are right next to each other, and so. But as we age, that collagen degrades, and when it degrades, canyons start to form where the cells are, and they come across as wrinkles. You got plenty here on me, and so in that scenario, you know people think, "Ooh, I need collagen," and they just imagine like I eat collagen. My body takes it and puts it where it's needed. That's not how our digestive system works. Collagen is a huge, huge protein. One of the biggest proteins out there. We eat it. We're digesting that down into the amino acids, and we're using those amino acids for everything in our body, like protein, any other protein. The difference is is what our body is really needing. What letters it's needing are the ones that can't make itself, and collagen doesn't provide a lot of those.
Turo Virta:So, and this kind of leads the next question. What I wanted to ask is that if someone's choice is between spending money on whey or some other complete protein or collagen, how would you decide?
Unknown:I tell them collagen is not the way to go. Yeah, that is a very easy answer. Yeah, you know, if you're looking to kind of improve your wrinkles like three to 5%, then yes. But I think actually there's probably more economical ways to do it that can give you a bigger benefit. Like skincare regimens are going to be better at doing that than kind of supplementing with a collagen. And it's a shame, right? Because what you're needing is that 60 to 100 grams of protein to give to be a complete protein, meaning those 20 amino acids, and so people are actually potentially harming themselves when they're assuming I'm getting all this protein from collagen when they're not getting those essential amino acids, and then you can actually now increase the rate at which your muscles are shrinking as you get older.
Turo Virta:So, is last question about collagen: Is collagen worth the money, or are women usually being sold extremely expensive protein powder with better marketing?
Unknown:Yeah, I'm going to say 8020 on that. Is it worth the money? Well, if you're spending very little on it, then yes. If you're spending a lot, then no. And there's really no difference between the types of collagen people type two, type three, type four collagen. Your body's going to break it down into the amino acids, and so don't get caught up in that. You know, type two is for my joints, type four is for my skin. It's it's all kind of gobbledygook, and your body's just going to break them down into the individual letters and reassemble those letters into your own body, and so you can stimulate your own collagen production. So I don't want to say it's not pointless, but I would not use it as a protein supplement. I would use it and say, okay, I'm looking, and most of them where they look at the improvement in wrinkles and joint, they're taking I think roughly five to 15 grams of collagen a day.
Turo Virta:So it's not that much actually. Would
Unknown:yeah.
Turo Virta:What about then other big supplement vitamin D? So who actually needs vitamin D?
Unknown:So you know you told me which ones are not necessary, and I said pretty much all of them. But vitamin D in today's world is a pretty good one to take. I'm sitting inside. I actually closed my shade so the sun doesn't come in on me. I'm inside for eight to 10 hours a day. I'm heavily clothed, and I have very little access to the sun. Well, I have a lot of access to the sun, but today's environment doesn't give me the opportunity. And so, I believe supplementation is, as I said before, it our environments change faster than we can evolve. And so, like right now in today's world, we're all sitting behind screens. We're not out in the sun, and so our environment has changed faster than we can evolve. And so, we used to, if we go back 20, 30,000 years ago, we were in the sun a lot, and our body utilized that sun to kind of help create and utilize that vitamin D. So, vitamin D supplementation is good. I think it is something that the bulk of individuals probably should take, just because we're indoors so much, we're not in the sun, and a good thing to kind of help us get that proper vitamin D. And so that is the one vitamin that I would say the general public typically tends to be a little low on is that vitamin D and
Turo Virta:yeah no I wanted to ask how then for who how much of sunlight or what kind of sunlight would you need or you need to get enough vitamin D through the sun
Unknown:oh. That's a good question, and I'm trying to pull up my memory. And I want to say I remember a report that it was about two to three hours of like moderate intensity sunlight a day. And so you know, there's different intensities of the sunlight. You don't want to be out too much where it burns you.
Turo Virta:Yeah.
Unknown:But like especially the morning and the evening sunlight seems to be the best. And so getting about two to three hours during the morning and the evening sunlight is a good way, and so those individuals probably don't need supplementation with the vitamin D. But you know, a typical morning for me is I'm driving in my car while the sun is coming up. I'm not really getting that sunlight. I wish I could be out walking, you know, and so forth, but yeah, that about two to three hours, I think, are what the reports say. But I'm I'd have to take a little bit more creatine to remember those reports.
Turo Virta:Yeah, yeah. What is then? Is there is there what is what actually if you are tested, what counts as a deficiency in vitamin D.
Unknown:What was that again? Sorry.
Turo Virta:Yeah. What actually counts as deficiency in vitamin D? Oh,
Unknown:that that is good, right? Because there is the recommendation of you know I think it's like 10,000 IU's a day is typically what they would want to have consumed, and when you get your blood levels tested, there's huge variance in the human population of what those vitamin D levels are, and this is maybe more of a philosophical question. I do believe diversity in health is important. So I am six foot four. I'm a pretty tall individual, and and so because of my height, I'm 10% more likely to get cancer because I just have more cells in my body. And so modern medicine would say, "Whoa, we need to get rid of some of your cells. Let's cut you off at the ankles." And now we just decreased your chance of cancer by 10 percent. But that's that doesn't seem very practical, logical, or ethical. I am just inherently going to be more susceptible to cancer because of my height. And in some cases, I think modern medicine has said we are all supposed to fit into this very specific bucket. We're supposed to have 120 over 80 blood pressure. We are supposed to have this amount of vitamin D. When in actuality, life is a bell curve, and it may do more harm trying to push people into the box of what is considered optimal health than there. And so, I'm not a huge fan of kind of saying this is what optimal levels should be. I am a huge fan of kind of saying, "Do you feel good?"
Turo Virta:Yeah,
Unknown:and kind of being in touch with that body and being like, "Oh, hey, I actually feel a little bit better when I do take more vitamin D, even though my levels are healthy. When I take more, I feel more energetic because I do believe, like trying to fit everyone into a narrow box, it's not good, and that diversity is very important for life.
Turo Virta:What about the next one, magnesium? So, is magnesium as useful for sleep and stress as social media assists?
Unknown:Yeah, I will say nothing is ever as good as what social media suggests. So no, but there was one study. The studies on magnesium and sleep are mixed, but the most comprehensive study where they did a placebo-controlled study, they gave you know 100 people magnesium. They gave 100 people a placebo, and they looked at what's called the insomnia score index. So the lower the score, the better your sleep. And these individuals had trouble sleeping, and those that took magnesium lowered their score drastically. The problem was is so did the placebo group. Now the magnesium group lowered. There's more than the placebo group, but they both went down. And so the effect of magnesium to baseline was huge, but the effect of the placebo was moderate. Now it was still statistically significant, but it was moderate. What I wish they did in this study is they only did it for 28 days. Is I wish they went out 60 or 90 days because usually what happens is you'll get that placebo effect for the first 30 days, then the placebo effect wears off. But true effect continues to show improvement, and so I wish they continued that study a little bit longer. But the big thing that also was very powerful in that study is they showed individuals who consume less magnesium in their diet actually responded better to the magnesium supplement in sleep. So not only did they show improvements in sleep with magnesium more than the control, but the individuals who. Who were more depleted in magnesium through their diet had a better response to magnesium. Again, suggesting that magnesium does help with sleep, but it's never it's not a sleeping pill. You can take it in the morning, you can take it midday or at night, and it all works the same. You know, it's not like I take it at night and I fall asleep like a melatonin, and so I would say it provides a moderate impact in helping with sleep, but it's a very cost-effective way to do it, right? And so this is where I look at individuals. You could spend hundreds and hundreds of dollars getting a fancy device to help you sleep, but typical magnesium glycinate is going to cost you maybe $10 a month to help you get that improvement in sleep.
Turo Virta:Yeah. What about what is evidence then saying for was it being used for also muscle recovery, cramps, anxiety? So what? How strong is the evidence for each of those?
Unknown:Not super strong. The best stuff that we have out there for anxiety is actually some different adaptogenic herbs. Ashwagandha, saffron are the ones that kind of show the best with respect to depression and anxiety in that area. Magnesium, I would say, mixed at best of showing an impact in those areas. There is significant evidence with magnesium in cardiovascular health, though, and that's not talked a lot. But yeah, people who supplement with magnesium are significantly less likely to develop cardiovascular issues later in life, and so there is benefit in that area of magnesium in the heart. So I think in that scenario. But if you're looking for mental health aspects, usually saffron and ashwagandha are top the list in that evidence.
Turo Virta:Then, what about omega trees? Like you mentioned, that if you already if you live somewhere in Japan and eating already a lot of fish, you probably don't need it. And then, if you don't, you probably need it, or it would be beneficial. Does that does it matter more than the big like fish oil 100 milligram number on the front? Yeah.
Unknown:So there's two different types of omega three. There's your EPA and your DHA, right? You really just want those to be roughly about the same amount, 50-5060-4050-50. It's the same, and that dose of getting it is the most important, right? You want it around 1000 milligrams a day, but the key is is what omegas are is they make up your cellular membrane, specifically of your red blood cells, and so in the United States, the average person is right around 4%, and at 4% and lower, you are a significantly higher risk for cardiovascular disease. You're at 7% or above; you're very less likely to develop heart disease or cardiovascular issues. And so, it takes about nine months of supplementing with omega threes to finally get your levels up to that 7%, because your your red blood cells have to die, new ones get made, and they get made with that omega three that's circulating in your blood, and so it's important to kind of do and take omegas on a regular basis to kind of get them incorporated into your red blood cell membranes, and so I actually have a test that I'm going to do here that measures my omega threes, and so this is like something I think I just interviewed, kind of the leading expert in omega threes. He spent 30 years of his life researching it, and you know there's mixed results. Some studies say, "Hey, it's not super impact. Omegas are not huge impact on health." But I would say the evidence that suggests that it is impactful on our health greatly outweighs that which it says it's not. So, getting your omega threes up is very important. People talking about the ratios of omega three and omega six. That's garbage. Not point. It's not relevant. Really, just look at getting your omegas is key.
Turo Virta:Makes sense. What about then a little bit what you would skip? So what what is what popular supplement do you think most healthy adults are wasting money on?
Unknown:I'm going to say a multivitamin is a big one. Collagen is probably a big one, and I'm. Going to say most of your greens powders, right? Just eat some fruits and vegetables. That's the way to go.
Turo Virta:Yeah. And what about then all those detox products or fat burners?
Unknown:Yes. There's no. There's nothing that's going to really accelerate those fat burners. Those types of stuff, yeah. There might be things that kind of suppress your appetite a little, so you eat fewer calories. But at the end of the day, it is calories in, calories out. And so, you know, people who consume caffeine, their appetite goes down a little bit. So you can say, hey, you know, caffeine can work decrease your appetite. But that's kind of where we're at.
Turo Virta:What about then if you are choosing which supplement you decide to take supplement, and because I see third party tested, it's everywhere in the label. So what does that phrase actually tell me?
Unknown:Yeah. So third party tested. What that means is it's a third party lab that's tested the the supplement to make sure it has what it says it is. Third-party lab it tested it's everywhere. What I would look for is do they actually reveal what the lab, who the lab is, and what the lab results are, and that is a key, right? And so you're wanting that level of transparency. If they're advertising Third party tested. It should hopefully they kind of say this is the lab that tested, and these are the results of what it tested.
Turo Virta:What about then if if let's say that does a more expensive supplement usually mean a better supplement? Because obviously they claim that it's better quality or whatever, but what is your opinion? Yeah,
Unknown:I am not a believer in that at all. Again, kind of going back to what they showed at Consumer Labs, to where they tested a whole bunch of ashwagandhas and found that there was no correlation between price and active ingredient. And so I do think that a lot of times it's like wine, right? We don't know necessarily what makes a good bottle of wine, but if it costs $1,000, it's a good bottle of wine. If it costs $10, it's not a good bottle of wine. And we just kind of throw those numbers out there. And so, because consumers may not know what makes a good supplement and a bad supplement, people will say, you know what? Let's charge a lot of money for it, and then people automatically think it's a premium product. Yeah, but again, it's largely just a few suppliers that are creating all of the raw ingredients that every brand is out there using.
Turo Virta:Yeah, it's old wine example. It's I we we in this area where I live, there is a lot of wine wineries, and when I talk that you, if you somebody is charging 1000 euro, is it that okay? You can justify maybe 50 euro or $50, maybe a little bit more for for a good bottle of wine. But if everything above that price, it's only marketing, or obviously if it's years, it it's like a 50 years old or something very yeah, where it becomes
Unknown:a collector's item type thing. Yeah,
Turo Virta:yeah. So that is that is the thing. Last two
questions:What would you recommend to typical penalty 48 years? old women.
Unknown:Yeah, I think protein supplementation is key. Huge amount of evidence, growing evidence with respect to creatine, especially during menopause. I'm helping with that, and an omega if they're like on a Western diet, and so the key is is maintaining that muscle mass. That is a huge part, specifically for women, of one mitigating the impact of menopause. The more muscle you have, the less symptoms you have of menopause, and so maintaining that muscle mass, getting them to go to lift weights, using protein and creatine to help maintain that muscle mass is is key. And I think in that scenario, right? I think there are four behaviors that largely
determine our health:how well we sleep, how how good we eat, how well we move, like a frequency of exercise, and how we regulate stress. And so, are we the you know are we getting good sleep? Are we eating well? Are we exercising? And are we meditating for meditative practices? And when we have those four areas under control, life is pretty good. And so we should just supplement to which of those areas we may not be well, and oh, my sleep's a little off. Okay, maybe look at some magnesium, or oh, my I'm not getting out what I needed from exercising. Okay, well, let's look at doing some creatine, right, and to kind of help with that.
Turo Virta:Yeah, no makes
Unknown:sense. So last, I think you should be supplementing to those behaviors rather than.
Turo Virta:No, that I hope it makes sense. It makes at least so much sense to me that there is no point of taking everything, and and it says that basically, like you, that was so such a good metaphor that it depends on better outside how you are, what kind of clothes you put on yourself. What about then? If somebody has only, let's say, $50.50 euros per month to improve their health, should they even spend it on the supplements?
Unknown:Ah, no. If you only have $50 to spend, put it in the bank, right? Save it. The mental, the mental health of having money in the bank is probably one of the best things that you could do rather than to supplement. But if you, in addition to saving, if you're looking at it, I would say probably creatine is where you do because it's just hard to get it from your diet. Protein I can get from my diet. Omegas I can get from my diet, vitamin D I can get from walking outside, creatine it's tough to get through your diet, so that would probably be the one. And realistically, right, you should only be paying 25 euro for 100 servings of creatine.
Turo Virta:Yeah, it's very unique. You're paying
Unknown:like you know eight euros a month.
Turo Virta:Yeah, yeah. No, no, that make makes sense. And it's it's it's cheap. It's there is such a such a big evidence behind it. So awesome! Thank you so much, Turo. Where can people learn more about you and listen to the Doctor Plant podcast.
Unknown:For people who are wanting to punish themselves and listen to more of me as a scientist, you can find the Doctor Plant podcast. I'm on social media, Doctor Plant, where I try to give kind of relevant information on supplements, and yeah, in the Dr. Pop podcast, what I do is I interview academics, the professors that research this, to kind of say, "Hey, is there too much hype on this, or is there not? What should people do?" And to try to to try to not allow social media to amplify stuff one way or the other, but to get to the source of all the research, and so every week I interview a new professor who is studying a different area of supplementation.
Turo Virta:Awesome! That sounds very, very interesting, at least for me. So, thank you so much, Josh. I really, really enjoyed talking with you learned again so much, and thank you for explaining it like very complex topics with such an easy language that I think it's it's very easy also for people who are not PhDs to understand what it means, what makes sense, what probably is waste of money. That was such a helpful episode. So thank you so much for taking your time. It's been
Unknown:an absolute pleasure. You're a great host, and yeah, hopefully everyone out there got a little information, save them a little money, and improve their health.
Turo Virta:Thank you so much, and thank you for listening. And if you enjoyed the episode, please leave a five-star rating. Share this episode with one of your friends, who you might think that would benefit, or who is taking all the time collagen protein to hear what Josh said about it. So thank you for listening, and talk to you soon.