FitMitTuro Fitness Podcast

Supplements After 40: What’s Worth Your Money and What Isn’t? with Dr. Joshua Plant

• Turo Virta

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:00:25

Send us Fan Mail

Walk into a health store or spend five minutes on social media and you’ll find supplements promising better sleep, more energy, faster fat loss, stronger muscles, better hormones, improved brain health and even longer life.

But which supplements are actually worth taking?

And which ones are mostly expensive marketing?

In this episode, I sit down with Dr. Joshua Plant, who holds a PhD in Biomedical Sciences from Harvard University, has worked in cancer research and spent around two decades in the supplement industry.

Josh is also the founder of The Science Standard and host of The Dr. Plant Podcast, where he focuses on what the evidence actually says about supplements, quality and health claims.  

One of the biggest ideas from our conversation is simple:

Supplements should supplement something. They shouldn’t replace the fundamentals.

Josh compares supplements to clothing. You don’t wear the same clothes in every season. In the same way, what you might benefit from can depend on your diet, age, lifestyle, sleep, stress and activity level.  

We talk about creatine, protein powder, collagen, vitamin D, magnesium, omega-3s, multivitamins, greens powders, fat burners and more.

Josh explains why he considers creatine one of the strongest options for adults over 40, particularly because of its role in training performance and growing interest around cognitive health.  

We also discuss why protein powder can be useful mainly because it makes it easier to increase protein without adding a huge amount of calories, but why whole-food protein should still make up most of the diet.  

And we go deep on collagen.

Josh explains why collagen is not a complete protein, why it shouldn’t replace whey or another complete protein source, and why its potential benefits for skin and joint comfort are much more modest than many marketing claims suggest.  

We also talk about:

  • why most people may be taking too many supplements
  • why multivitamins are often unnecessary
  • the risk of getting too much of certain nutrients
  • why supplements are so easy to over-market
  • how to decide whether you actually need a supplement
  • creatine after 40
  • creatine and cognitive health
  • protein powder versus whole foods
  • whey versus plant-based protein
  • whether expensive protein powder is actually better
  • collagen for skin and joints
  • why collagen should not replace regular protein
  • vitamin D
  • magnesium and sleep
  • omega-3s
  • greens powders
  • detox products
  • fat burners
  • third-party testing
  • why expensive supplements are not automatically better
  • what a healthy 48-year-old woman should actually prioritize
  • what Josh would buy if he only had €50 per month to improve his health

One of my favorite moments comes right at the end.

When I ask Josh whether someone with only €50 per month should spend it on supplements, his answer is basically:

No. Save your money first.

And if there were one supplement he’d prioritize because it is difficult to get meaningful amounts through food, he would lean toward creatine.  

Connect with Dr. Joshua Plant:

The Science Standard:
https://www.thesciencestandard.com/

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/drjoshplant/

LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/joshua-plant-phd-980552337/

The Dr. Plant Podcast on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/@DrPlantPodcast


Learn more about Turo and FitMitTuro:

Website & Coaching:
https://personaltrainerturo.it

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/personaltrainer_turo

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@personaltrainer_turo

FitMitTuro Fitness Podcast:
https://www.fitmitturo.com/

Apple Podcasts:
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/fitmitturo-fitness-podcast/id1512446261

Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/1VLf4hjt7M3tho6AURKJqa

Try The Consistency Reset

My new personalized coaching app for women 35–55 who are tired of starting over with diets, workouts, and healthy habits.

Get simple daily actions, realistic workouts, practical nutrition habits, and Reset Mode to help you keep going when life gets busy.

Take the quiz and build your personalized plan here: studio.com/turo/consistency-reset